Are strategic defaults a moral issue or a business decision? You decide. Walking away, however, does carries repercussions:
My advice for Baby Boomers? Talk to a CPA and/or attorney before making the decision to walk away from your home. DO NOT talk to the lender(s), as this will just raise a red flag and add to your stress. Understand your options and consequences. Then make the best business decision for your circumstances.
Some advice - stay away from short sales UNLESS you are working with an expert Realtor and the property has already been pre-approved by the lender(s) who is (are) taking it in the shorts. Watch out for liens on short-sale properties that may become your responsibility! Bank-owned properties that being marketed by a Realtor, on the other hand, can be outstanding buys. Thinking about buying a foreclosure? Well, be prepared to pay all cash and then go through several rounds before you win a bid. And even then, you get the property "as is," so be sure to have a professional inspection before placing a bid.
Also, loans are hard to get these days, so clean up your credit and talk to a mortgage professional about qualifying ratios before doing anything.
Let's face it - Fate has crapped on the retirement savings of Baby Boomers, but there are still abundant opportunities to retire in a nice place if you make lemonade out of lemons.
Renting is a good way to find out if you like a community enough to retire there. It gives you a local base to learn about surrounding home values, the people and amenities. Financially, renting instead of buying retains liquidity, a consideration in these uncertain times. And don't worry that all the hot real estate values are going to disappear in the next year or so. As a real estate broker, I can tell you that in many areas of the country we are going to see continuing waves of foreclosures for the foreseeable future. This economy has got a long ways to go - years in fact - before it gets healthy again.
For you Baby Boomers out there who are wrestling with your diminished retirement situation, it's interesting to see that many are making a business decision to walk away from upside-down mortgages:
Guess Who's Ditching Their Mortgages?
A study of 24 million credit files by national credit bureau Experian and consulting company Oliver Wyman has shown that home owners with high credit scores are 50 percent more likely to deliberately walk away from a mortgage than lower-scoring borrowers.
The industry calls these “strategic defaults” and their numbers grew to 588,000 in 2008, double the total in 2007, and well beyond most earlier estimates.
The study determined:
Strategic defaulters tend to go straight from paying their mortgages dependably to not paying at all. Strategic defaulters are heavily concentrated in negative-equity markets like California and Florida. Two-thirds of strategic defaulters have only one mortgage. Most likely to default are home owners with large balances and the highest credit ratings.
Piyush Tantia, an Oliver Wyman partner and a principal researcher on the study, said strategic defaulters "are clearly sophisticated” and look on the decision to default as a business strategy. "Well, I'm $200,000 in the hole on my house, and yes, I'll damage my credit," Tantia says of defaulters.
Source: Washington Post Writers Group, Kenneth R. Harney (09/27/2009)
I don't know why everyone is surprised. After all, our generation has been left hanging in the wind. There is no economic help headed our way. We've seen our home equity evaporate and our savings slashed...all through no fault of our own. And we are completely on our own. You have to make the best decision for your circumstances.
Just a word of advice - be aware that you will not be able to get another home loan for as long as seven years if you ditch your current mortgage. And it will severely impact your credit score. So the lesson is, do everything you need to do (like buying or renting another home) before defaulting on your mortgage!